Katgirl900214's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[UDE]

Well, I like it..

From my point of view this game is really good. I think the reason people are giving it low scores is because they are comparing it to some other popular warfare/RPG/other great game.

See this is just a free flash game, and so it will never really be perfect. But for what it is i think it's pretty impressive. It's not easy to make a fully functional flash game, especially with such nice graphics. People should review it for what it is. Not what it could be.

Yes it could be better if you had tons of money, but you don't and I get that. I think it was a very good attempt, and a very popular concept. As I stated above the graphics were wonderful. I really like the moon-like terrain and the bot designs.

As for the two races ( Tridalian, and Idatu) I thought they were equally in balance. See the Tridalian favor speed, while the Idatu favor power. It is fair for the Tridalian to have faster enemies, but that is what makes them better. Same for the Idatu. They're enemies are slow but much more powerful.

The game was based on warfare so I didn't worry to much about the main character upgrades, because to me it's not the hero that matters it's his soldiers. Because the hero cannot survive on his own he needs soldiers to back him up. You could have the most powerful hero ever in the game but it wouldn't matter if all your soldiers sucked. So to me the while upgrading the hero thing didn't bug me at all.

Overall 9/10. I only have but a few suggestions. First is to be able to switch weapons on the hero. For example, the main weapon is a single shooter, then you can switch to another weapon which is automatic (but then you have to collect ammo for it). Also another thing that would be nice is to updgrade individual bots. Like it would be nice to upgrade the speed for the Idatus protos. My last suggestion is to add a third race. A race that has both an equal balance between power and speed. This adds even more fun because then the higher levels can have 3 races all fighting at once, adding difficulty and fun.

Again I know this isn't going to the BEST version of the concept ever, but by making this I think you have shown you have the potential to make great things. Overall 9/10. And please make a sequel. I look forward to it!

episodeent responds:

Thank you very-very much for your understanding, your support and constructive feedback!

[Lastman3 (World1)]

Very cool game

I don't think it's much of a knock off at all. The way I see it is like "Super meat boy". It's similar to mario, but it's much more difficult. This is one of those games that is so awesome, but too difficult for noobish people so they retaliate by giving it a low score and coming up with a cruddy excuse for why they couldn't win. I liked it. It's a good game.

PiGPEN responds:

Well it isn't different from Mario just because it's hard... the Mario series itself has at least one super hard game (SMB2jp). Admittedly Lastman3 is Mario inspired but there's tons of functionality differences.... skills learned in Mario do not apply to Lastman3 anymore than they would apply to S.MeatBoy or Umihara Kawase or Atlantis no Nazo (although if you're skilled at platforming in Atlantis no Nazo it may help somewhat at Lastman3).

[Escape from ice mountain]

Glitchy

I know you only had 72 hours to make this game, but it's very glitchy. I can't even win it because it won't grab the key. Next time I would worry more about the programming rather than the art.

MonoFlauta responds:

You cant grab the key because you dont have the polehook, not becaues a glitch :) see the walktrough before giving a low score because you cant win :)

[Newgrounds medals: EXT]

Thank you!

Thank you so much! Both of your guides have helped me get a ton of medals!

EventHorizon responds:

thanks, and I'm happy for you! :)

[Target-Shooting]

Very simple idea

I thought it was very way displayed for the idea you were trying to represent. It would be cool if you expanded on it sometime. My high score was 45.

Yusuf responds:

thanks!

[Rooftop Raiser]

For all those low raters

for whoever gave the game a low score, its not about the game its the message there trying to send.

Matmi responds:

cheers:)

[Black Ants Rescue]

Pretty good

Fun, physics game. 9/10 because the graphics weren't that great.

@registar: stop being a bitch

KingDotCom responds:

Thanks!

[Crap Game Compilation 2]

My only complaint

.. at the end of each game should be a link to go back to the main menu.

JonBro responds:

Actually, you can return to the menu at any point in any of the games. It's a button in the top-left corner of the screen. I tried to make it subtle so it wouldn't be distracting but I can understand if it's too unnoticeable.

[GTA3: The Flash Version]

I feel bad

For all the losers who actually try to play this as a game...

KovioXZ responds:

me 2

[Swim Mr. Fish]

Kinda Confused..

Why is everyone giving this game a bad review? I mean the game is all right, but just because you can't play well is no reason to give a game a bad review. For example, I realize it was hard, but thats the point. My only problem was the coins though. It says if you get 10 coins you get health, but it is almost impossible to get most coins without losing health, and them when you get 10 you get hardly any health. The controls were fine, the graphics were good (the fish was cute :)) overall 9/10

dudejonne responds:

Thank you! :-)